vestwell vestwell vestwell
  • About
  • Contact
  • Testimonials
  • More
    • Demographics & Advertising Rates
    • Terms & Conditions
Monday, May 23, 2022
No Result
View All Result
CALIFORNIA BUSINESS JOURNAL
  • Front Page
  • Business
  • Finance
  • People
  • Featured
  • Technology
  • Law
  • News
  • Food
  • Art & Culture
  • Human Interest
  • Education
  • Insurance
  • Real Estate
  • Health & Fitness
CALIFORNIA BUSINESS JOURNAL
american-flag

Dreamers Won Full Restoration of DACA…What Now?

Despite overwhelming public support for DACA and repeated public advocacy by U.S. businesses urging the government to keep the program in place, Dreamers continue to live a nightmare of uncertainty.

by California Business Journal Editorial Staff
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Nearly six months after the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the Trump administration’s termination of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program was unlawful, the government refused to comply with the ruling, sending Dreamers back to court to enforce it.

On Dec. 4, a federal court in New York ordered the government to fully reinstate DACA to its Obama-era terms. Three days later, the Department of Homeland Security announced it would comply with the order and begin to accept first-time DACA requests and restore other terms of the program it had taken away, such as “advance parole,” which allows Dreamers to travel abroad and return to the U.S., thereby opening a narrow pathway for permanent residence for a small class of Dreamers. Meanwhile, President-elect Joe Biden has promised to reinstate DACA on his first day in office, to work toward a permanent legislative fix and provide a pathway to citizenship for all undocumented immigrants.

Despite these indisputable victories, here’s why it’s too early to celebrate. An existential threat to DACA looms in the form of a pending lawsuit in Texas federal court that directly grapples with whether the original DACA program is lawful in the first place—a question no court has addressed (although three dissenting Supreme Court Justices characterized DACA as “unlawful from its inception”).

ADVERTISEMENT

The Texas court’s history with DACA-related litigation does not bode well for Dreamers: In 2015, Judge Andrew S. Hanen blocked the Obama administration from introducing the DAPA program, an expansion of DACA that shielded undocumented parents of U.S. citizens and green card holders from deportation. The decision only narrowly survived appeal, when the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals agreed and an eight-member Supreme Court (following the death of Antonin Scalia) split evenly, leaving in place the injunction on DAPA, which never took effect.

After President Trump took office, his Acting Secretary of Homeland Security issued a September 2017 memorandum rescinding the DACA program. But the rescission was immediately challenged and a judge in California ordered the administration to maintain the program. In response, Texas and other conservative states filed a new complaint in the Texas court, this time seeking to dismantle DACA as “unlawful.” In August 2018, Judge Hanen ruled that DACA “violates the substantive provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act,” but somewhat surprisingly left DACA in place.

Questioning why the states did not challenge DACA itself in their original 2014 suit against DAPA, he noted the significant hardship to the estimated 800,000 Dreamers, and concluded that a temporary injunction would not repair an “egg [that] has [already] been scrambled.” Importantly, however, Judge Hanen also said that “DACA and DAPA are basically identical, and there is no legal ground for striking DAPA that wouldn’t apply to DACA.” The states are now asking the court to declare that DACA is unlawful and order its termination. A hearing is set for Tuesday, December 22.

The stakes could not be higher for Dreamers. Judge Hanen has already signaled that DACA is likely to suffer the same fate as DAPA and could strike down DACA as early as Tuesday. If the case winds up in the Supreme Court, it will be a different and more hostile forum with the addition of Justice Amy Coney Barrett, who, as a judge on the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals, authored a 40-page dissent siding with the Trump administration on the controversial pubic charge rule.

Of course, the battle will continue—and with renewed vigor under a new administration that has promised to “reinstate” DACA and protect Dreamers. Congress, too, may eventually step up, but that seems like a distant possibility in this stridently hyper-partisan environment. Meanwhile, despite overwhelming public support for DACA and repeated public advocacy by U.S. businesses urging the government to keep the program in place, Dreamers continue to live a nightmare of uncertainty.

Article written by Martin Robles-Avila, a Senior Counsel in the San Francisco office of Berry Appleman & Leiden LLP, an award-winning global immigration firm. He works on the full spectrum of employment-based matters and closely follows litigation trends at the U.S. Supreme Court and the federal courts affecting immigration and criminal issues. He recently spoke on a panel about DACA for a Spanish broadcast for the group America Sin Muros.

Tags: 2018Americaaward-winningCaliforniaDACADreamersgreengreen cardGroupHearingimmigrantsimmigrationJoe BidenlitigationNew YorkSan FranciscoSupreme CourtTexasTrumpU.S. businesses
ADVERTISEMENT
California Business Journal Editorial Staff

California Business Journal Editorial Staff

Related Posts

Commentary: Immigration Processing Delays are Hurting U.S. Business
government-procurement
How To Calculate The Value of Private and Public Procurement Contracts
USA immigration
America’s Real Immigration Crisis: Billions Left on the (Visa) Line
DACA
Congress Must Act Now to Protect Dreamers—the Economic Recovery Can’t Wait
US immigration
Foreign-Worker Wage Hikes Coming, DOL Lets Employers Weigh In
advertisement
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Instagram LinkedIn

Advertise With CBJ

1REALTOUR-SAN DIEGO-WEB DESIGN
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn LinkedIn Instagram
C B J   LOGO  SVG-01
  • About
  • Contact California Business Journal
  • Testimonials
  • Demographics & Advertising Rates
  • Terms & Conditions

Categories

  • Art & Culture
  • Business
  • Editor's Choice
  • Education
  • Featured
  • Finance
  • Food & Dining
  • Health & Fitness
  • Human Interest
  • Insurance
  • Law
  • Marketing
  • Medical
  • News
  • Newsletter
  • People
  • Popular
  • Real Estate
  • Social Media
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized

CBJ Partner Firebrand Media

Laguna Beach Independent Newspaper
 Laguna Beach City Guide
 Newport Beach Independent Newspaper
Newport Beach Country Club Magazine
  Montage Magazine
 Omni Escapes Hotel Magazine
 Bespoke Concierge New York
 Evans Hotels
 Laguna Beach Magazine
 On The Menu Laguna Beach
 Newport Beach Magazine
Coastal Real Estate Guide (NB,LB, CDM)
Monarch Beach Resort Magazine
 Pacific Coast Magazine (SoCal)
Sea Island Life Magazine
Salamander Hotel & Resorts Magazine
 View our entire portfolio

 

Most Viewed

  • Gavel, scales of justice and law books

    Lawsuit Basics: How Much Does It Cost to Sue Someone?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • NFL Paychecks: How Do NFL Players Get Paid?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Impact of Covid: Racing to Buy Second Citizenships

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • What to Do When an Online Casino Refuses to Pay Out Your Winnings

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • New Study: California’s 10 Universities That Produce the Most CEOs

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Five Reasons Why The Government Does Not Like Bitcoin

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Only Way

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Is Virtual Financial the Future of Financial Services?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • How to Start a Telecommunication Business: A Step-By-Step Guide

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Best Crypto Faucets You Can Try In 2021 and 2022

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Latest Articles

Chicago

What You Should Not Miss When Visiting Chicago

Personal injury

What can I expect my personal injury protection to cover

las vegas

3 Tips to Win More Money When Visiting Las Vegas

How Can You Put Green Papua Kratom To The Best Possible Use -- Pexels.com

How Can You Put Green Papua Kratom To The Best Possible Use

arbitrage betting

How to Find the Best Arbitrage Betting Opportunities

Santa Monica, California

The Middle Class: 5 Best Places to Live in Los Angeles for Families

high heels banned in carmel, california2

Some of the Most Unusual Laws You’ll Ever Experience in the UK and California

Contractor

How To Find a Trustworthy Contractor

Online Bingo Tips

Online Bingo Tips For Beginners: How To Play And How To Get Free Spins

John Cooke, Partner, Bergston LLP

The Legal Side of Things: Business Profile on John D. Cooke, Bergeson, LLP

California Business Journal | California Business News, California News Media, California business articles | Orange County, Los Angeles, San Diego, Inland Empire, Northern California, San Francisco | Huntington Beach CA 92649 | (949) 648-3815
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED BY CALIFORNIA BUSINESS JOURNAL.
Site Design by 1REALTOUR

No Result
View All Result
  • Front Page
  • Business
  • Finance
  • People
  • Featured
  • Technology
  • Law
  • News
  • Food
  • Art & Culture
  • Human Interest
  • Education
  • Insurance
  • Real Estate
  • Health & Fitness

California Business Journal | California Business News, California News Media, California business articles | Orange County, Los Angeles, San Diego, Inland Empire, Northern California, San Francisco | Huntington Beach CA 92649 | (949) 648-3815
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED BY CALIFORNIA BUSINESS JOURNAL.
Site Design by 1REALTOUR