Branden Pearson explores what it means to approach negative feedback with grace and self-compassion.
Most of us are generous with grace, right up until it is our turn to receive it. We will talk a friend down after a rough performance review or a stinging email, then turn around and let one piece of criticism about our own work run on a loop. A single sharp comment can outweigh a dozen kind ones, and before long, a passing judgment starts to feel like a verdict on who we are.
That reflex shows up wherever feedback does: a client's pushback, a teammate's note, a one-star review, an offhand remark that lingers far longer than it should. The hard part is rarely the feedback itself. It is the weight we add to it, and how fast we let one data point stand in for the whole picture.
Branden Pearson, a Project Leader at Boston Consulting Group who advises industrial clients on operations and transformation, works in a field where the feedback never stops. Client reactions, team reviews, and pushback on recommendations are part of the job. On his Substack, he writes about giving yourself grace while doing demanding work, learning to speak to yourself the way you would speak to a friend, and letting a mistake be a moment instead of a verdict. His approach comes down to a simple discipline: keep what helps you grow, and let the rest go.
The False Weight of Negative Experiences
Negativity bias is strong, a fact confirmed over the years by research. Emotions that feel bad, such as embarrassment or sorrow, seem to linger longer than those that feel good, such as happiness. And if someone doesn’t like a restaurant and leaves a scathing review, it seems to carry more weight than a single glowing one. In many people’s eyes, it takes numerous positive reviews to outweigh a single negative one.
For reasons psychology has yet to fully explain, negatives carry more mental and emotional weight. Humans remember the bad things, like insults, more than the good things, like praise. That negativity bias can make a single bad review, of any kind, seem like the end of the world, or at least the end of a product, career step, or friendship.
But that weight isn’t real and often comes from an internal response to negative feedback. In reality, research shows that most people don’t understand how much others like them. A discrepancy called “the liking gap” leads people to believe others see them more negatively than they actually are, which can make a single poor review feel like the whole story rather than a small slice of communication.
On his Substack, Pearson notes that it’s easy to be harder on yourself when life becomes challenging. He writes that during such a time in his life, he broke through negative cycles when he “stopped believing the lies of the enemy” (referring to his faith). He writes, “The lies are loud, but they are not true. The enemy whispers that you are not worthy, but the truth is you are loved (Jeremiah 31:3). He says you are defined by your failures, but the truth is you are being made new (2 Corinthians 5:17).”
Why Self-Compassion and Grace Are Important
“Grace changes things,” Pearson writes in his Substack post. He means the grace of Christian Scripture. But even for individuals of differing faiths, grace and self-compassion are important according to science. Pearson has made a parallel case about how we can show respect and compassion even through small gestures, and self-compassion is that same attentiveness turned inward.
A study from the University of California, Berkeley examined what happens when you treat yourself with compassion after a mistake by analyzing four experiments:
How people thought about their personal weaknesses
The level of motivation someone had to avoid moral failings or make amends
How much time someone spent studying for a test after doing poorly on one
How motivated someone was to change an identified weakness
The researchers found that self-compassion, including accepting failures gracefully and not making more out of a single incident than necessary, motivated people across all four experiments to improve.
Pearson explores this topic in a Substack post about running with a friend who slows her pace so he can keep up. In thinking about that, he doesn’t end with a conclusion that indicts his own slowness. Instead, he recognizes the grace the other runner has for him, and he considers the situation with self-compassion, which lets him come to a different and more valuable conclusion.
“We were never called to cross the finish line first,” he writes. “And I am not sure we were even called to cross it on our own terms. We were called to help the people on our left and on our right keep moving forward.”
Dwelling on Negative Feedback Has Downsides
Even those with thick skin, who normally shake off a bad review or poor feedback, can get caught in the doubt trap. “Doubt is sneaky,” Pearson writes in another blog post. “It rarely walks in the front door announcing itself. It comes in as worry, as a worst-case scenario rehearsed at 2 a.m…”
That’s exactly how you might find yourself dwelling on a single negative statement from someone else. But research from Harvard Health says sliding into that cycle has ramifications for mental and physical health. Rumination, which is the term for what happens when you can’t stop overthinking something, may increase a person’s vulnerability to anxiety, depression, and challenges like insomnia.
Creating Valuable Feedback Loops
As a project leader and consultant, Pearson knows the value of feedback. Data and reviews are critical information points, and the conclusions you draw from them can help make or break the success of any initiative.
So how do you maintain perspective and avoid letting a single negative review derail you? According to Pearson, it’s about patterns and understanding self-worth.
Look for patterns, not just single data points. A consultant shouldn’t rebuild an entire strategy based on one survey response. Trends matter.
Ask for feedback often. Don’t be afraid to ask those around you for honest feedback or request that customers leave reviews. More feedback reduces the weight of each response, which can lessen the sting of a negative response.
Build a network you can trust. Not everyone’s feedback is relevant or high quality. Think about who you need to hear from and how much their response should sway you.
Keep a record of positive feedback. Gratitude journaling is a recognized tactic for building appreciation and love of the world around you. The opposite works too; a record of the things people say you’ve done well can help you get through challenging days or get some perspective when a negative review leaves you spinning.
None of this makes the hard feedback stop coming, and it is not meant to. The goal is not a thicker skin or a higher rating. It is perspective: taking what is useful, extending yourself the same grace you would hand anyone else, and letting a single review be a moment rather than a verdict. One piece of feedback, good or bad, was never the whole story. It is one line in a much longer one you are still writing.
The views expressed here are his own and do not represent those of Pearson’s employer or its clients.




