• About
  • Contact
  • Testimonials
  • Newsletter
  • More
    • Demographics & Advertising Rates
    • Terms & Conditions
Friday, February 3, 2023
No Result
View All Result
California Business Journal
  • Front Page
  • Business
  • Finance
  • People
  • Featured
  • Opinion
  • Technology
  • Law
  • News
  • Food
  • Art & Culture
  • Human Interest
  • Education
  • Insurance
  • Real Estate
  • Health & Fitness
California Business Journal
LA at night

LA at night

WHY $15B CORP FLEES CALIFORNIA …

by Rick Weinberg, Editor in Chief, California Business Journal
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

For Tax Purposes. What Else?

Edited By Rick Weinberg, California Business Journal 

Breathtaking California beach


How important is it for businesses to be in a tax-friendly state?

It’s everything.

Even the breathtaking beaches, the dazzling mountains and national parks, the beautiful hot desert, the Silicon Valley influence — and the most gorgeous weather in the world — isn’t even to keep businesses from fleeing the Golden State of California because of high taxes.

Add Jacobs Engineering Group Inc. to the list.

One of the world’s top engineering and architecture firm, Jacobs has approximately $15 billion in revenues.

This is a huge finance kick in the groin to California.

With marquee design firms like Jacobs competitors HKS Inc., RTKL, Page Southerland Page, Perkins & Will already in downtown Dallas, HKS CEO Dan Noble wasn’t surprised by Jacobs’ California defection.

“The move is being made for business reasons, such as lower taxes and the business friendly environment,” Noble told the Dallas Business Journal. “The rates in downtown are also less than in the suburbs and the quality of life in downtown Dallas has a buzz about it.”

So, California’s so-called “hostile business environment” continues to drive thousands of companies away.

A study conducted by Joseph Vranich, president of Spectrum Locations Solutions, a consultant firm in Irvine, Calif., quantified the trend of companies fleeing California and determined how, and to what extent, it is caused by California’s “hostile” business environment.

Using publicly available records, mostly media and government reports, Vranich searched for what he calls “California divestment events” — business decisions to shun the state.

ADVERTISEMENT

These come in three types: companies that left the state entirely; companies that expanded in other states rather than in California; and a few companies that had planned to grow in the Golden State but changed their minds.

Calif LA disney at nightVranich found records of 1,510 divestment events occurring in California between 2008 and 2014.

Yet, according to a report in the National Review, that number is an incomplete accounting of the situation.

“Experts in site selection generally agree that at least five events fail to become public knowledge for every one that does,” Vranich  wrote in his study, concluding that the real total is probably more than 9,000 divestment events for this period.

Even that estimate may not tell the full story, according to the National Review.

Small businesses are less likely to get media coverage when they relocate, but they are the biggest category of divestment events.

The cost and compliance burdens of California’s taxes and regulations fall disproportionately on smaller companies, which are less able to afford the teams of attorneys and accountants that mega-corporations can employ.

Calif palmsAs Carly Fiorina ably pointed out during the GOP debates, big government tends to benefit big business.

To no one’s surprise, Texas was the main beneficiary of California divestment events during each year of the study.

Following Texas, the top destinations for “escaping” California businesses were Nevada, Arizona, Colorado, Washington, Oregon, North Carolina, Florida, Georgia, and Virginia.

Calif desert sunset cloudsCalifornia’s elected officials do not appear to care too much about businesses leaving the state. Yet the problem is real.

Vranich has been conducting similar studies and publicly sharing his findings about thousands of ex-California companies since 2010. Yet despite all the evidence, Governor Jerry Brown has made several public statements denying a “mass exodus” of California businesses.

Brown reportedly has a long history of making excuses when businesses reject his state.

When Toyota announced it was uprooting three California plants and consolidating its headquarters in Plano, Texas, the Wall Street Journal quoted Brown as saying, “We’ve got a few problems. We have lots of little burdens and regulations and taxes.

“But smart people figure out how to make it.”

The Journal’s reply: “California’s problem is that smart people have figured out they can make it better elsewhere.”

OK, so Silicon Valley has enjoyed a boom in the last few years. However, as The Economist noted last year, “whereas venture-capitalists and coders may be rushing to California, others cannot wait to leave,” as the state still faces substantial problems of its own making.

Calif snow on mt“Beyond the gilded strip of land between San Francisco and San Jose is another California, an inhospitable place plagued by over-regulation, mindless bureaucracy, high taxes and endless lawsuits,” — in addition to the nation’s highest income-tax rate and highest minimum wage.”

Texas Public Policy Foundation’s Chuck DeVore served in the California state assembly from 2004 and 2010 and he has written about the vastly different approaches to tax policy and economic regulation found in California and Texas.

He echoes The Economist’s pessimism about California’s ability to sustain the current tech boom, let alone expand on it to benefit the rest of the state.

In recent years, he says, “California’s job market has rebounded on the strength of Pacific Rim markets, Silicon Valley, and the creative industries. But the Golden State’s big-government-knows-best policymakers continue to export jobs from more traditional sectors of the economy. The net result is a widening rift between the elites who live within ten miles of the Pacific and the rest of the state. It’s only a matter of time before California’s high-tax, heavy-regulation policies will cause the state to once again lead the nation in job losses.”

And low-tax, business-friendly Texas is be the biggest beneficiary.

According to Vranich, businesses leaving California experience substantial cost savings, ranging from 20 to 35 percent.

And burdensome rules add to the financial factors that influence a company’s decision to relocate.

Calif beachAs The Economist describes: Entrepreneurs who survive the ordeal of gathering all the permits needed to start a business — opening a restaurant can take more than two years in California — are then micromanaged by labor laws telling them when to pay overtime, and how much.

They suffer electricity prices that are already among America’s highest, and which may rise further to meet the state government’s ambitious carbon-emissions goals.

Then there is the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).

A well-intentioned law to curb the damaging effects of development has mutated into a monster.

Almost anyone can file a CEQA lawsuit against any project they dislike; plaintiffs win half of the cases they enter, and when they lose, they do not need to cover defendants’ legal fees (the reverse does not apply).

Builders are compelled to hire expensive unionized labor to ward off union bosses’ threats of spurious CEQA suits.

Shops and petrol stations file cases to prevent competitors from opening up.

The full extent of the damage these regulations have done to California’s economy is impossible to calculate, but Vranich highlights several key areas of impact.

Calif mt poppiesBesides the job losses, he found evidence of at least $62 billion in capital that was diverted to other locations.

Additionally, the loss of so many business owners and their employees has had a negative impact on California charities.

Companies that have left California brought with them the people who donated to California philanthropies, organized new charitable organizations, and volunteered their time.

Texas cities were well represented on the list of top destinations for discontented California businesses.

Austin was No. 1, and Dallas, Houston, Irving, Plano, and Fort Worth were also listed.

Charles Schwab’s move to Austin exemplifies this trend.

As the Austin Business Journal reported, the discount brokerage “has been adding almost 1,000 jobs here as it retreats from pricey San Francisco.”

DeVore observes that businesses leave California for Texas for reasons beyond just lower costs, pointing to the Lone Star State’s hospitable regulatory climate.

Calif mt sunrise mistBeyond the direct dollar savings, businesses moving to Texas benefit from “stronger property rights that enable companies to build new headquarters and factories in months as opposed to the years it takes in California.”

Unfortunately for the companies still left in California, their future in the Golden State is far from bright, according to Vranich, who points out that state officials are currently considering enacting still more taxes and fees on businesses in 2016 and 2017, which would “trigger the worst demands on private-sector finances ever organized by the state’s politicians.”

 

 

Tags: accountingAmericaarchitectureAustinbusinesses leaving California for TexasCaliforniaCEOcompliancecost savingsDallasdevelopmenteconomyelectricityemployeesentrepreneursenvironmentalfinanceGrouphigh taxesHoustonIrvineJacobs Engineering Group Inc.JerryjobsJoseph VranichLandlawlawsuitsNevadaregulationsregulatorySan FranciscosavingsSilicon ValleySpectrum Locations SolutionsState of CaliforniastudytaxtaxesTexasValleywall street
ADVERTISEMENT
Rick Weinberg, Editor in Chief, California Business Journal

Rick Weinberg, Editor in Chief, California Business Journal

Rick Weinberg is Editor-in-Chief at California Business Journal. He is a well-known writer, reporter and on-air talent who has worked for the New York Times, FOX and ESPN. He launched California Business Journal to focus on California businesses and business professionals as well as California business news and information. Contact: Rick@CalBizJournal.com / 949-648-3815

advertisement
ADVERTISEMENT

CBJ Newsletter

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Instagram LinkedIn

Advertise With CBJ

Contact Rick@CalBizJournal.com

CBJ Rates and Demographics

Job Postings

CEO Wanted


Requirements: BS/BA + 2yrs of Business Managing Experience

Mail Resume: Grand Life, Inc. 14647 Northam St. La Mirada, CA 90638.

$114,754/year

ADVERTISEMENT
1REALTOUR-SAN DIEGO-WEB DESIGN
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn LinkedIn Instagram
C B J   LOGO  SVG-01
  • About
  • Contact California Business Journal
  • Testimonials
  • Demographics & Advertising Rates
  • Terms & Conditions

Categories

  • Art & Culture
  • Business
  • California Hotel Listings
  • Daily Updates
  • Editor's Choice
  • Education
  • Featured
  • Finance
  • Food & Dining
  • Health & Fitness
  • Human Interest
  • Insurance
  • Law
  • Lawyers
  • Marketing
  • Medical
  • News
  • Newsletter
  • Opinion
  • People
  • Popular
  • Real Estate
  • Social Media
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized

CBJ Partner Firebrand Media

Laguna Beach Independent Newspaper
 Laguna Beach City Guide
 Newport Beach Independent Newspaper
Newport Beach Country Club Magazine
  Montage Magazine
 Omni Escapes Hotel Magazine
 Bespoke Concierge New York
 Evans Hotels
 Laguna Beach Magazine
 On The Menu Laguna Beach
 Newport Beach Magazine
Coastal Real Estate Guide (NB,LB, CDM)
Monarch Beach Resort Magazine
 Pacific Coast Magazine (SoCal)
Sea Island Life Magazine
Salamander Hotel & Resorts Magazine
 View our entire portfolio

 

Most Viewed

  • Gavel, scales of justice and law books

    Lawsuit Basics: How Much Does It Cost to Sue Someone?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Investigation: Can TriumphFX Take Your Money?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • The Impact of Covid: Racing to Buy Second Citizenships

    3 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • What to Do When an Online Casino Refuses to Pay Out Your Winnings

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Top 5 Flavors On Elf Bar BC5000 Review

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • NFL Paychecks: How Do NFL Players Get Paid?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Five Reasons Why The Government Does Not Like Bitcoin

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • How to Start a Telecommunication Business: A Step-By-Step Guide

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • 6 Types of Business Records and Receipts Every Small Business Should Keep

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Temu’s New Shipping Policy Is A Smashing Hit For Shoppers All Over the Country

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Latest Articles

Q&A with Jennifer Woods, Vice President and Associate General Counsel of FrontDoor on Why Companies Should Release Sustainability Reports.

Q&A with Jennifer Woods, Vice President and Associate General Counsel of FrontDoor on Why Companies Should Release Sustainability Reports.

Best Practices for Establishing Secure Password Protocols

Best Practices for Establishing Secure Password Protocols

How to Up Your Marketing Game with Real Estate 3D Rendering

How to Up Your Marketing Game with Real Estate 3D Rendering

Tips For Designing A Vinyl Banner For Your Business

Tips For Designing A Vinyl Banner For Your Business

15 Useful Animation Makers for Novice Entrepreneurs (2023)

15 Useful Animation Makers for Novice Entrepreneurs For 2023

What is FinTech?

What is FinTech?

IT Company Tips: How to Develop IoT Mobile App

IT Company Tips: How to Develop IoT Mobile App

Offline Marketing Strategies for Brand Visibility and Awareness

Offline Marketing Strategies for Brand Visibility and Awareness

Around the U.S.: Benefits of Getting a Loan From Hard Money Lending in Colorado

Around the U.S.: Benefits of Getting a Loan From Hard Money Lending in Colorado

6 Easy Ways to Win the Online Casino

6 Easy Ways to Win the Online Casino

California Business Journal | California Business News, California News Media, California business articles | Orange County, Los Angeles, San Diego, Inland Empire, Northern California, San Francisco | Huntington Beach CA 92649 | (949) 648-3815
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED BY CALIFORNIA BUSINESS JOURNAL.
Site Design by 1REALTOUR

No Result
View All Result
  • Front Page
  • Business
  • Finance
  • People
  • Featured
  • Opinion
  • Technology
  • Law
  • News
  • Food
  • Art & Culture
  • Human Interest
  • Education
  • Insurance
  • Real Estate
  • Health & Fitness

California Business Journal | California Business News, California News Media, California business articles | Orange County, Los Angeles, San Diego, Inland Empire, Northern California, San Francisco | Huntington Beach CA 92649 | (949) 648-3815
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED BY CALIFORNIA BUSINESS JOURNAL.
Site Design by 1REALTOUR